How To Tell If A Wooden Door Needs To Be Replaced Or Just Repaired

November 2, 2023


Doors are a crucial component of any home, not only serving functional roles but also adding to the aesthetic appeal. Whether it’s interior or exterior doors, knowing when to repair or replace them is important. In this article, we’ll offer some ways to decide which course of action is appropriate.

Evaluate the Door’s Condition and Functionality

  • Examine for Cracks or Other Damage – Wooden doors with minor cracks might be repaired, but extensive damage might necessitate replacement.
  • Functionality Issues – Doors that are hard to open, close, or lock might require repair or even replacement. It could be a sign of wear that can be repaired, but if it persists, replacement may be necessary.

Assess Structural and Physical Deterioration

  • Check for Sagging or Misalignment – This could be a sign of serous structural problems that may require a new door.
  • Physical Deterioration – Cracking, peeling, or warping, especially in wooden doors, could signify that the doors are falling apart, leading to replacement.

Evaluate Weather Stripping and Seals

  • Weather Stripping and Seals -For exterior doors, damaged weather stripping might need to be replaced. Severely degraded seals may require replacing the entire door.
  • Drafty Doors – These can increase energy costs and make your home uncomfortable. Replacement with modern options can be a long-term solution.

Aesthetic and Energy Efficiency

  • Aesthetic Considerations – Outdated or inconsistent doors might be replaced to align with the home’s décor.
  • Energy Efficiency – Older, outdated wooden doors may be replaced with fiberglass or metal for better energy efficiency.

Look for Rot, Moisture Damage, and Other Growing Issues

  • Rot and Moisture Damage – Extensive rot in wood doors might require replacement.
  • Small but Growing Issues – Rust, corrosion, or insect damage can escalate, leading to replacement.

Safety and Noise Considerations

  • Safety Concerns– Loose older doors might pose a security risk. Modern materials offer better protection.
  • Increased Noise – Older doors losing their sound barrier may be replaced with more effective noise-reducing options.


Knowing when to repair or replace your doors involves evaluating various factors including their condition, functionality, aesthetics, energy efficiency, and safety. The right action safeguards both appearance and security of your home while potentially saving on energy costs and enhancing curb appeal.

Ask the Experts

For more advice about whether to repair or replace your doors, check with the experts here at Mans Lumber & Home. We are a custom millwork shop offering premium moldings and lumber. Since 1900, the Mans family has served the lumber and building material needs of the Metro Detroit and Ann Arbor communities. Over 100 years later, we continue to operate our company with a customer centered focus. Our employees undergo continuous training and education to ensure that our customers have access to the latest product information and building techniques. With locations in Trenton, Canton, Birmingham, and Ann Arbor, we concentrate on providing quality building materials and outstanding customer service. If you would like more information about the products and services we offer, visit our website, give us a call at 734-237-7914, or drop by any of our four locations. We look forward to serving you!